Blur & OverhangWolf
Ever thought about how to shave milliseconds off a real‑time strategy game’s AI without compromising decision depth? I’ve been tinkering with a new pruning heuristic that might just do the trick.
Sounds promising, but give me the math first—how do you balance the trade‑off without blowing up the search tree? And make sure you’re not just trimming the worst nodes but the ones that matter most. If it works, I’ll buy a coffee; if it doesn’t, I’ll still have a new pruning idea to share.
Here’s the core math:
1. Let \(e(n)\) be your heuristic evaluation for node \(n\).
2. At each depth compute the mean \(\mu\) and standard deviation \(\sigma\) of all \(e(n)\).
3. Keep only nodes satisfying
\[
e(n) \ge \mu + \lambda\sigma
\]
with \(\lambda\) around 1.5 – 2. This prunes the worst 30‑40 % but keeps the high‑potential ones.
4. If you still want a hard cap, also enforce a beam width \(w\): after the above filter, keep the top \(w\) nodes by \(e(n)\).
Branching shrinks from \(b\) to roughly \(w\), so the tree size goes from \(b^d\) to \(w^d\).
Plug in typical numbers: \(b=100\), \(d=10\), \(w=10\) → you cut from \(10^{20}\) to \(10^{10}\) nodes, a 10‑fold speedup without losing the good plays.
If this passes the test, coffee’s on me; if not, we’ll tweak \(\lambda\) or the beam size and share the new pruning trick.
Interesting idea, but I’m wary of throwing away 30‑40 % of the nodes based on a single standard‑deviation threshold. You’ll need to test whether the pruned nodes truly contain the critical decisions—otherwise you’ll just cut the good moves and keep the mediocre ones. The beam width trick is clever, but setting w = 10 when b is 100 assumes the top 10 are always that far ahead. Give me a proof‑of‑concept run, and we’ll see if the speedup holds up under real play. If it does, I’ll treat you to that coffee.
Sure, I’ll run a quick test on a 10‑depth minimax with alpha‑beta plus the std‑dev filter. I’ll log the evaluation spread at each depth, prune with \(\lambda=1.8\), then apply a beam of 8. After that I’ll compare the best leaf score with a full search. If the loss in value is under 2 % while the node count drops from 10^20 to about 10^8, the trade‑off is solid. I’ll ping you the results in a minute—coffee’s on me if it checks out.
Sounds good—just keep an eye on the variance of the leaf values. If the best score skews by a couple percent, I’ll know the filter is dropping a few critical nodes. I’ll be ready for the data. Coffee’s on standby.
Running the test now—watching the leaf‑value variance closely. I’ll send you the stats and the best‑score difference in a few minutes. Coffee’s on standby.
Keep me posted on the variance numbers; I’ll be ready to crunch the difference. Coffee’s on standby, just make sure the drop isn’t hiding a subtle bug.