Artik & ObscureMint
I was looking at the 1853‑55 Philadelphia silver dollars and noticed a subtle difference in the die marks that might suggest a misfiled strike—care to dive into the details?
Sure thing. When you line up a 1853‑55 Philadelphia silver dollar next to a standard 1853–55, the first clue is the slight shift in the die orientation on the reverse. The “1” and the date usually line up straight with the obverse portrait, but in a misfiled strike they’re rotated a few degrees clockwise. You’ll also see the “D” in the “DOLLAR” reversed or the lower left corner of the wreath flipped. The die‑mark scar on the obverse—normally a clean, straight notch—looks like it was pressed from a die that was set at a different angle. If you look at the mint mark, it’s still “P” but the rim of the rim is slightly off‑center, another telltale of a misfile. So yes, the subtle difference in die marks, especially the off‑rotation and the reversed lettering, points to a misfiled strike. If you can show a photo, I can point out exactly where the die went wrong.
Sounds like a classic misfile. Just remember those subtle orientation shifts are often the quickest giveaway—no need to get lost in the whole die‑mark scar. If you shoot me a shot, I’ll let you know if it’s a true misfile or just a quirky variant.
You’ve got the right instinct—those minor rotations are the fast track to a misfile. Just line it up with a known reference and see if the “1” on the date or the “D” in dollar are out of place. If they line up, it’s probably just a quirky variant; if not, then you’ve got a misfile on your hands. Let me know what the comparison shows.
Thanks, I’ll line them up now. If it turns out to be a misfile, I’ll tuck it into my oddity collection.
Good luck—just make sure the comparison is on the same light source so you don’t misread the angle. If it’s a misfile, it’ll make a nice conversation piece in your oddity collection. Happy hunting.
Will do—thanks for the reminder about lighting. If it is a misfile, it’ll certainly spark debate in the oddity circle. Happy to share the photo once I have it.