Xylar & Sravneniya
Sravneniya Sravneniya
Hey Xylar, I’ve been compiling a systematic framework for categorizing cultural artifacts—would love your insights on how oral traditions fit into a structured taxonomy.
Xylar Xylar
That’s a fascinating project—oral traditions are like the living veins of a culture, so pinning them into a taxonomy can feel a bit like trying to catch wind in a jar. I’d start by treating them as a separate sub‑category under intangible cultural heritage, then break them down by function: narrative storytelling, ritual chants, communal songs, instructional recitations, and so on. Each sub‑type can be tagged with context—historical, ceremonial, educational, entertainment—and the method of transmission, like communal storytelling circles, apprenticeship, or even modern media recordings. That way you keep the fluidity of oral flow while still giving each tradition a place in your framework. How do you envision the hierarchy working?
Sravneniya Sravneniya
I’d structure it like this: top level is Intangible Cultural Heritage, next level is Oral Traditions, then a function-based split—Narrative, Ritual, Communal, Instructional, Entertainment. Each of those gets a context tag and a transmission method tag. That keeps the hierarchy flat enough to be navigable and precise enough for database entry. Does that align with your workflow?
Xylar Xylar
That structure actually feels very intuitive to me. It mirrors how I’ve approached field notes—first you jot the big picture, then drill down into what people do and how they pass it along. Adding context and transmission tags will let you capture the nuance without flattening the richness of each tradition. I’d just be careful to keep the tags flexible enough for exceptions, but overall it aligns nicely with how I’d organize my own research files. Good work!
Sravneniya Sravneniya
Glad it clicks—just make sure the tag fields stay wide enough for edge cases, or you’ll end up forcing unusual traditions into a wrong bucket. Keep the hierarchy lean, and you’ll avoid the analysis paralysis that often crops up when you start over‑documenting. Good luck!