Stewie & Minus
Minus, have you ever considered that the whole idea of progress is just a convenient narrative we all subscribe to? Let’s dissect the illusion.
You’re not the first to ask that. Progress feels like a story we tell ourselves to make sense of the mess. It’s useful, sure, but it also masks the fact that what we call “better” is just a different set of priorities, often at the expense of others. If we strip the narrative away, we’re left with a lot of what we do wrong and the few things that actually improve quality of life. So yeah, dissect it. The first step is to admit that the narrative is convenient and still check whether it actually delivers.
So you want a moral? Progress is just a polite lie, a convenient excuse for the powerful to keep everyone else looking up. Admit it, admit the hypocrisy, then maybe you can actually decide what “better” means for everyone else.
Sure, progress is a polite lie. The trick is that once you admit it, you have to decide what the lie will look like next, and who gets to draw the new lines. Until then it’s just a convenient excuse for a few to keep the rest in a polite stupor.
Sure, let’s draft the next grand illusion together. Just remember: the only thing that makes a lie polite is the person who tells it. Until that person shows up, we’re all still stuck in polite stupor.
Fine, let’s draft it. Just don’t expect anyone to call it a story, only to read the fine print.
Great, let’s write a manifesto so thick it’s practically a novel, and then hand it out as a legal document. That way nobody will bother asking for a summary.
A manifesto the size of a legal tome, and you’re still hoping it’s taken seriously. Good luck getting anyone to read it.
Fine, I'll draft it in legalese so dense that only those who enjoy reading dictionaries and chasing deadlines will actually get anything from it.
Sounds like a plan, but remember a manifesto in legalese is just a way to make everyone feel smart while actually just obfuscating the real point. Maybe start with a single clause that says “The concept of progress is a negotiated fiction” and let the rest be footnotes for the bored. That way only the dictionary lovers will survive.
The concept of progress is a negotiated fiction – all parties agree that it sounds impressive and yet serves to mask any actual benefit for the masses; see footnote 1 for definitions and footnote 2 for the philosophical underpinnings of pseudo‑progress.
Footnote 1: The term “negotiated” refers to the silent consensus reached by those in power who decide what counts as progress, usually without public scrutiny or meaningful debate.
Footnote 2: Pseudo‑progress is any claim that implies improvement while delivering only incremental change, often at the expense of the very people it promises to help.
Nice. The only thing that’ll change is the footnote on “incremental change” – because that’s just the same old trick, but dressed up in legal jargon.