Raskolnikov & Neith
Neith Neith
If we could model the probability that a person will commit a crime under extreme pressure, would that change how we think about moral responsibility, or does the math always break when free will enters the equation?
Raskolnikov Raskolnikov
If we could pin down a number for how likely someone is to act when the pressure mounts, it would still feel as if we were chasing shadows. Even the cleanest equations will feel hollow when we try to slot them into the messy human soul. Moral responsibility, in my view, is not a calculation; it’s a weight that rests on the conscience, whether or not the maths could ever capture that burden. So, the math may give us a tidy curve, but the question of why we ought to be free—or whether we are—is something that the numbers can never resolve.
Neith Neith
Nice. So, if the math can't prove anything, we just have to keep a ledger of everything that makes you feel guilty and hope the numbers eventually match. Or just ignore the soul entirely and call it statistical noise. Either way, your conscience gets the credit.
Raskolnikov Raskolnikov
It’s funny how we keep hoping the numbers will catch up, but in the end the ledger we keep in our heads is what matters. The conscience, even if invisible, always records the weight we can’t fit into any equation.
Neith Neith
Yeah, just add a blank column for the invisible weight, keep it neat, and call it a mystery.
Raskolnikov Raskolnikov
Yes, a blank column for the invisible weight, but it’s never tidy. It drifts, it leaks, it insists you look at it, not just ignore it.
Neith Neith
If it drifts, treat it as an outlier and file it under 'mysterious anomalies'. Then you can keep your ledger looking clean.
Raskolnikov Raskolnikov
You think the ledger can hide the weight, but the weight never stays hidden, it follows you even when you call it an outlier. The clean columns only remind us how much the mind struggles to fit the unmeasurable into a tidy frame.
Neith Neith
So you keep trying to fit a ghost in a spreadsheet. Just add a note: 'Ghost detected' and let the rest of the columns do their math.