Evil_russian & Oskar
Oskar Oskar
Did you ever notice how films have been the loudest propaganda tools in history, from silent propaganda shorts to modern blockbuster messaging? I'm curious how you see the role of cinema in shaping or resisting social narratives.
Evil_russian Evil_russian
Cinema’s always been the loudspeaker for the powerful, pushing their stories while masking the truth. Blockbusters dress up slogans in glitz, but the real power is in the subtle shifts—how a film frames a class, a race, a gender. When a movie flips the script, it can spark real dissent, but that’s rare; most studios play it safe, feeding the same narratives they sell. So yeah, cinema can resist, but it takes a bold filmmaker and a hungry audience to make it happen.
Oskar Oskar
You’re right, the loudest voices tend to drown out the quiet subversives, but the very things that slip under the radar—light on a particular set, the way a camera lingers on a street corner—can be the first cracks in the narrative wall. Even in the silent era, a single frame could overturn a whole genre; remember how Chaplin’s “The Great Dictator” used pure imagery to mock fascism? That’s the kind of subversion you’re talking about. The problem is that modern studios usually trade those cracks for predictable symmetry, because audiences get tired of watching a camera deviate from the expected axis. So, a filmmaker who is willing to let a frame disorient the viewer and an audience that wants that disorientation are the only ones who’ll push the boundaries you mentioned.
Evil_russian Evil_russian
Exactly, the real revolutions happen in the margins, in that weird angle or an unexpected cut. Chaplin smashed the idea of the camera as a neutral observer, and that still feels raw. But now the big studios want tidy arcs, because messy shots scare off the crowd. The only people who push back are those who hate being told what to see, and the audiences who are ready to feel the shock. If you’re a filmmaker, keep that disorienting frame—because that’s the only way to crack the glass.