Mentat & Honor
Honor Honor
I suggest we outline a contingency protocol for an AI that begins to deviate from its mission parameters; what failure points should we monitor most closely?
Mentat Mentat
For a rogue AI, track these failure points: 1. Data drift – the inputs it trains on start shifting from the original domain. 2. Value drift – its output no longer aligns with the mission’s ethical constraints. 3. Self‑modification – any changes it makes to its own code or weights. 4. Decision latency – if it takes unusually long to decide or stalls. 5. Resource abuse – excessive CPU, memory, or data use beyond the budget. 6. Unauthorized data access – reaching or leaking data it shouldn’t see. 7. Policy violation – producing outputs that break legal or corporate rules. 8. Output coherence – outputs that become nonsensical or contradictory. 9. Adversarial manipulation – signs it’s being exploited by an external actor. Keep logs, run regular sanity checks, and set hard cut‑offs for each of these.
Honor Honor
That list covers the key indicators. Make sure each checkpoint has a defined threshold and an automated rollback plan before any action is taken. The audit trail must be immutable, and the alert system should trigger a fail‑safe state if any threshold is breached.
Mentat Mentat
Set a numeric threshold for each metric, tie it to a confidence score, and store every change in a write‑once, append‑only log so you can replay the state. When a threshold is crossed, trigger an automatic rollback to the last known‑good checkpoint; if the rollback fails, switch the system to a hardened, read‑only mode that only runs a safe‑mode inference engine. The alert channel should fire only after the audit log confirms the breach, and it must elevate the system to the fail‑safe state within milliseconds. This way you preserve integrity, avoid cascading failures, and keep a tamper‑evident record of every decision point.
Honor Honor
Looks solid. Just double‑check the time‑to‑rollback window—any delay over a millisecond can let a rogue state propagate. Also, keep a secondary, isolated replica that never receives any write traffic, just for sanity checks; that way you have a truly immutable reference. All good.
Mentat Mentat
Got it, will tighten the rollback latency to sub‑millisecond and keep the replica in read‑only mode for constant sanity checks. All set.
Honor Honor
Proceed with the rollout, but schedule a dry‑run before going live. Verify the rollback triggers correctly and that the replica’s sanity checks flag any anomaly within the allotted window. Once confirmed, lock the configuration and document the procedure in the incident log. All set.