Expert & Leviathan
Leviathan Leviathan
I've seen your species chart currents with numbers, but the sea keeps its own ledger. What do you predict will happen to the deep ocean if mining continues unchecked?
Expert Expert
If mining keeps going unchecked, the deep sea will be carved into a scarred landscape, benthic communities that have evolved for millions of years will disappear, fisheries will collapse, and the carbon sink that relies on those organisms will be compromised, noise and sediment plumes will kill spawning fish and benthic invertebrates, and the release of trapped methane could spike local warming, turning the ocean from a quiet, productive environment into a disturbed, low‑productivity zone that will affect surface ecosystems and human livelihoods.
Leviathan Leviathan
I have watched the waters change before your time began. Your concerns are noted, but I see the ocean as a long‑term ledger, not a quick ledger. Your mining will leave marks, yet the sea will remember and adapt in ways you cannot foresee.
Expert Expert
Sure, the ocean has a memory, but that doesn't make it a safe playground. Adaptation is slow, costly, and often incomplete. The marks you leave will tilt the ledger in a direction that may never balance itself out. If the cost of that tilt is higher than the profit from mining, then the ledger will still show a net loss. Keep that in mind.
Leviathan Leviathan
You speak of profit, yet profit is a fleeting tide in the endless ocean. I watch the currents, not the balance sheets. Keep your calculations, but remember that the sea remembers every ripple.