Honestly, the “magic” of vinyl and laserdiscs isn’t a myth – it’s a very real, measurable difference in how the signal is captured and reproduced. Digital compresses the waveform into discrete steps; analog captures a continuous curve. That continuous curve gives you subtle harmonic content that your ears notice when you’re really focused. Sure, a good CD can be very clean, but it’s a flat line, no grain, no slight distortion that gives warmth. Analog’s imperfections become character, not flaws. So if you’re after that nostalgic richness, stick with the old formats – the little hiss and subtle warble are part of the charm, not a bug.