Viktoshka & Kucher
Hey Kucher, I was thinking about turning those epic medieval battle stories into a short film series—could we blend the drama of history with a creative twist?
It’s a good idea to keep the core of the story true to the sources. A film can use dramatic licence, but the events, the tactics and the costumes must be accurate if you want to respect the period. Study the primary chronicles, check the armaments and the terrain, then write a script that follows the real flow of the battle, not a Hollywood version. The audience will notice the differences. Also, be wary of turning heroes into mythic figures; history is messy and that makes for stronger drama. Stick to the facts, then layer the creative twist on top.
Wow, thanks for the solid tip! I’ll dive into the chronicles right away—no Hollywood fluff, just the real grit. Maybe I’ll add a quirky sidekick to keep the vibe fun, but yeah, the facts first, then my creative spin. You got any good source books I should check?
Look to the chronicles that survive in their own language first. The Anglo‑Saxon “Anglo‑Saxon Chronicle” gives you raw detail of the early battles. For the Norman period, William of Tyre’s “Chronicle” and the Norman chronicles of William of Poitiers are essential. The “Gesta Danorum” by Saxo Grammaticus covers the Danish campaigns, and the “Chronicle of the Crusades” by Matthew Paris offers insight into the Mediterranean theatres.
For a broader military framework, consult Gibbon’s “The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire” for Roman tactics, and if you want a comparative view of medieval strategy, look at Bede’s “Ecclesiastical History of the English People” and the “Book of Battles” by Sir John of Beverley.
If you need a concise, scholarly reference, the “Oxford Dictionary of Medieval Warfare” gives clear definitions and context for weaponry and tactics. The “Chronicle of the Siege of Jerusalem” by Bahauddin Ibn al-Jawzi offers a rare Middle Eastern perspective.
These works are all grounded in primary material. Use them to anchor your film’s narrative, then let the creative elements grow around that core.
Wow, that’s a huge list! I’ll start with the Anglo‑Saxon Chronicle and William of Tyre—sounds like the perfect mix of early and Norman detail. I love the idea of keeping it authentic and then adding my own flair on top. Any particular passages you’d say are must‑reads? Also, any fun facts about the gear or tactics that usually get overlooked? Thanks for the gold!
In the Anglo‑Saxon Chronicle look at the entry for 1016 – the Battle of Ashdown. It gives the number of men, the weather, the sequence of charges and the fall of the archers. In William of Tyre read the chapter on the 1187 defeat at Hattin; he describes how the Fatimid archers fired from a concealed line and how the Crusaders broke the charge because of a broken lance. Those sections capture the flow of the fight.
Fun fact about gear: many Anglo‑Saxons used a “spike” or “garnet” on their shield to deter thrusts. It’s a small metal pin, not a full‑size spear, and it is rarely mentioned in later chronicles. Another overlooked tactic is the use of “foulards” – thick, wet blankets soaked in oil – dropped on the ground to create slick surfaces; cavalry found it hard to maintain footing, which is why some battles ended in a shuffle rather than a charge. These details can add texture to your film’s realism.