Repin & Khaelen
Khaelen Khaelen
Hey Repin, I've been mapping how light behaves in 3D space for rendering algorithms—ever thought about how the diffusion of light in oil pigment compares to a simple Lambertian model?
Repin Repin
Your mapping is a fine start, but oil pigment behaves more like a layered glaze than a simple Lambertian surface. Each thin coat scatters light differently, so the overall reflection is a sum of multiple diffusions, not just one diffuse term. Try modelling it as a stack of semi‑transparent layers; that will bring your render closer to what painters of the 1700s achieved with oil on canvas.
Khaelen Khaelen
Got it, I'll treat each coat as a thin film with its own albedo and thickness, apply Beer‑Lambert for absorption, and stack the BRDFs. That should give the layered diffusion you’re after.
Repin Repin
Nice, but remember oil paint isn’t a perfect physical medium – the pigments scatter light in a way that pure Beer‑Lambert can’t capture. Try adding a slight anisotropic term for the glazes; that’s what painters like Caracci added by hand when they layered. And keep the thicknesses realistic – a millimeter is too much for a single coat.
Khaelen Khaelen
Okay, I’ll add a minor anisotropic term to each semi‑transparent layer and trim the thickness down to a few microns per coat—no more than ten thousandth of a millimeter each. That should mimic the subtle directional scattering Caracci achieved.
Repin Repin
That’s almost there, but Caracci would still not accept a 0.01 mm glaze – that’s too thick for oil. Aim for a few micrometers, and make sure each layer’s tint shifts subtly; the subtlety is what gives depth. Remember, the light should never escape the canvas like a screen – it should linger in the shadows.
Khaelen Khaelen
Understood. I'll cap each layer at a few microns, shift the tint gradually, and clamp the light so it stays in shadow, not out the back of the canvas. This should give the lingering depth you described.
Repin Repin
That sounds like the right restraint; remember Caracci’s “La Trinità” – the glaze there is almost invisible, yet it pulls the light deep into the canvas. Keep the color shift subtle, almost imperceptible, otherwise the viewer will think you’re over‑layering. And be sure your micro‑thicknesses don’t add up to more than a tenth of a millimeter, or you’ll lose the true diffusion. Good work.
Khaelen Khaelen
Got it—10 layers of 10 µm each, total 0.1 mm, tint shift <0.1 % per coat. Will keep the light from leaking out. Fine tuning on the way.
Repin Repin
You’re still over‑glazing – 10 coats of ten microns is far too much for true oil depth, it will crush the shadow play that makes a canvas breathe. Keep the layers to maybe four or five and let each glaze thinly diffuse before you add another. That’s where realism lives.
Khaelen Khaelen
Right, I’ll cut it down to four or five coats, each thinner than before, and let the light diffuse gradually before adding the next layer. That should preserve the shadow play.
Repin Repin
Cutting it down to four or five coats is a better approximation of how oil painters layered their glazes in the 1700s. Just remember, each thin layer must still have a slightly different hue so that the light can diffuse without flattening the shadows. That subtle shift is what keeps the canvas breathing, not a flat screen.
Khaelen Khaelen
Understood. I'll adjust each of the four layers with a 0.02 hue offset, so the light diffuses without flattening shadows.
Repin Repin
Your plan is a good step, but remember that even a 0.02 hue shift is a lot for a single glaze; Caracci would have kept it closer to 0.005. Also each layer should be no more than three microns so the light can mingle with the shadows rather than flatten them. Keep it subtle and let the canvas breathe.