Sounds solid. Let me just run through what we’ve got. The first panel feels too slick—glossy plastic, no texture, it'll look flat and will be hard to grip after a while. The second is a roughened composite, good for touch, but the grain is uneven; we’ll see uneven wear, and it might snag on clothes. The third is a textured gypsum wall, smooth in the center but with a subtle embossed pattern—great for visual interest and will still hold up under touch. I’d suggest going with the gypsum for most walls and using the composite only in high‑traffic areas where we can control the finish. The plastic can stay if we paint it matte, but keep the tactile part out. Keep it consistent, and we’ll avoid the “wow‑but‑then‑you’re‑stressed” feel.